Twelfth night or what you will (1996) official trailer - ben kingsley, helena bonham carter movie hd - duration: 1:54 movieclips classic trailers 124,463 views. The duke of illyria in twelfth night and the soccer captain in she's the man, is in love with olivia in both olivia falls in love with viola, who was disguised as cesario in twelfth night, and sebastian, her twin brother in both movies, in she's the man. For the purposes of this question i will be refering to the film version of this play that came out in 1996 and was directed by trevor nunn, starring toby maguire and helena bonham carter.
The language in the movie she's the man is very much different than the language in twelfth night because of the vast variation between time set of the two plays and the writing characteristics used in them shakespeare used his language to convey a difference in feelings, attitudes, or personalities of characters in different. Twelfth night shakespeare homepage and yet i will not compare with an old man count's serving-man than ever she bestowed upon me. Viola in the twelfth night realizes that she has caused olivia to fall in love with her unintentionally she says she is the man as depicted by shakespeare (12) she then observes that by wearing male attire she is a creature that is both male and female and that she is a poor creature.
So if your reading this it means you want to know the differences between twelfth night and she's the man take the setting for example take the setting for example in the movie she's then man there is a kissing booth, debutant and a soccer tournament. She's the man is a 2006 american romantic comedy sports film directed by andy fickman and starring amanda bynes, channing tatum, laura ramsey and emily perkinsit is inspired by william shakespeare's play twelfth night. The easy answer is that twelfth night is a comedy (see our discussion of genre), so everybody has to get married at the end ok, sure, but we think we can do better than that ok, sure, but we think we can do better than that.
Man' could possibly be based off of shakespeare's twelfth night well it is, mostly being a modernized version of the movie, it is alike and different in many ways their basic plot is very. She's the man is set in the united states and most of the action happens at illyria, a boarding school the time of the setting is also quite different while shakespeare doesn't specify when twelfth night takes place, it isn't in modern times she's the man is a modern story with cars, soccer, and a junior league carnival. I didn't for one second believe the plot of she's the man, but i did believe for the entire movie that amanda bynes was lovable she plays a girl who pretends to be a boy in order to play soccer that this story is recycled from shakespeare's twelfth night is something i report right here at the. Below is an essay on comparison between twelfth night and she's the man from anti essays, your source for research papers, essays, and term paper examples she's the man vs twelfth night when we think of the story of cinderella, about eight different variations of the story from different times and cultures come to mind. When she leaves him, a few months later, to accompany her new husband to virginia (a colony that, um, did not yet exist), he begins to write twelfth night, inspired by his cross-dressing love.
Twelfth night and she's the man have the same theme of love where the main characters are connected in a love triangle disguise and jealousy, love and appearance versus realityare main themes characters genre twelfth night she's the man both twelfth night and she's the man are based around the same idea, however aiming at different audiences. But now i feel i have a better grasp on what the terms mean to me and will take one last look at two versions of the work as i analyze twelfth night and she's the man for me the adaptation of a work needs to be the actual plot of the original play. Twelfth night is a romantic comedy, and romantic love is the play's main focus despite the fact that the play offers a happy ending, in which the various lovers find one another and achieve wedded bliss, shakespeare shows that love can cause pain. Twelfth night, or what you will is a comedy by william shakespeare, believed to have been written around 1601-1602 as a twelfth night's entertainment for the close of the christmas season.
Both the twelfth night and she's the man have several similarities such as: same concept, same basic plot, character relationships, and character names for instance, in both the film and play viola pretends to be a male, but for different purposes in the twelfth night, viola does it to protect herself and also get love from orsino. The film is based on shakespeare's twelfth night which i have read and loved and seen on stage a few times so i certainly liked the references but whether you like shakespeare or not it won't matter - the movie stands on it's on. Best answer: 10 things i hate about you and taming of the shrew are the same as for shes the man its based on william shakespeare's play twelfth night, or what you will (which is another name for the same show.
These worksheets enable you to teach a unit on twelfth night by william shakespeare in comparison and conjunction with she's the man these printable resources deal with the themes and language of the two texts. The film she's the man is a modern adaption of the shakespearian comedy twelfth night at first glance, the film and play share apparent congruities however the differences and alterations that the screenplay writer and director have laid on top of the original play has transformed this traditional play in order to fit the mold and taste of modern audiences.